Finding out that a will doesn’t match what was promised changes everything overnight. Hillcrest advises Sydney families on contesting or challenging a will, and whether a claim is actually worth making.
Yes, if you fit one of the eligible categories and you act within twelve months of the date of death. People often say “contesting” when they mean two different things. A family provision claim says the will is valid, but didn’t leave you enough. Challenging a will says the will itself shouldn’t stand; maybe it wasn’t signed properly, maybe the person wasn’t of sound mind, maybe someone pushed them into changes near the end.
Spouses and children are usually eligible without much argument. De facto partners, too, in most cases. Grandparents and extended family can apply, but they’ll need to show real dependency, not just a connection. The twelve-month deadline isn’t always final. Courts can extend it. They just don’t do it often, and they want a good reason when asked.
This is a family provision claim, someone eligible, usually a spouse, child, or de facto partner, arguing the will didn’t leave them enough. It doesn’t matter whether the will is genuine. The question is fairness, not authenticity, and the court can redistribute the estate if the original split falls short.
This disputes the will’s validity itself, claiming it isn’t legally sound due to lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence, fraud, or improper execution. It’s not about fairness but legitimacy. If successful, the court can declare the will invalid, and an earlier valid will (or intestacy rules) applies instead.
Tamara has handled complex property disputes and contested estates for over a decade. This isn't general practice work picked up occasionally.
The procedure for family provision claims and will challenges differs between Sydney's court registries. That local detail shapes how a claim is run, not just how it's argued.
95% of estate disputes settle before trial, and the firm carries a 5.0 rating across 80+ reviews. Numbers a prospective client can verify, not just claim.
You can’t remove someone’s legal right to bring a family provision claim, whatever the will says. What you can do is make a successful claim less likely. Start with the record. A clear, dated note explaining why someone received less, or nothing, gives the court something to work with later.Â
Relationships count too, even difficult ones; cutting someone off rarely defeats a claim on its own. Some people add a statutory declaration at the time the will is made, not years after. For larger estates, certain assets can sit outside the estate entirely through trusts or nominated beneficiaries. That route needs real advice, not a template. None of it removes the risk. It just narrows it.
A short conversation can usually answer that. Hillcrest reviews the will, the relationship, and the time limit involved, then gives a clear view on whether contesting it makes sense before you commit to anything further.
Will disputes rarely move quickly, and clients know that going in. What they mention afterwards isn’t the timeline. It’s finally understanding whether contesting the will was worth it, and what the realistic options actually were.
5.0 Google Reviews
Naveen Khan
5.0 Google Reviews
“Highly recommend the services of Hillcrest lawyers! Tamara helped me construct and write my will. She’s very knowledgeable and honest with her clients. Her guidance and advice made writing a will very straightforward and easy. I would give beyond 5 stars if I could!Keep up the amazing work TamaraSuper strongly recommended 🙂
Thank you sooo much Tamara for all your hard work!”
Munna AI
5.0 Google Reviews
“I’ve had the pleasure of having Tamara as my Solicitor for the past 4 and a half years. I wouldn’t trust anyone else with my protecting myself and my son. I went to Tamara scared and broken and she fought for us and saved me from a life of panic and fear and saved my son from a very dangerous person. I can’t thank her enough for the empathy, strength and loyalty she provided me. Not only did I receive the outcome I wanted, I also gained a lifelong friend.”
Korelle
Most claims settle within six to twelve months. Mediation gets most of them there before a hearing’s even needed. A straightforward case might wrap up quickly. Add more parties, or a disputed asset or two, and a year can pass without much trouble. What actually drives the timeline isn’t the legal process. It’s whether the other side wants to talk.
Yes, within the twelve-month limit, though probate makes things slightly more complicated. Once a grant has been issued, the executor may have already started distributing assets, which can affect what’s recoverable. Acting before probate is granted, where possible, generally keeps more options open.
Sometimes, but the bar is higher than for spouses or children. Grandchildren usually need to show they were partly or wholly dependent on the deceased. Siblings aren’t automatically eligible under NSW law at all, and would typically need to fit another recognised category to bring a claim.
A missing or incorrect signature is one ground. So is a lack of mental capacity at the time the will was signed, where the person didn’t properly understand what they were doing. Undue influence is another, someone pushing or pressuring the decision. Forgery and outright fraud come up, too, less often, and usually in wills that were changed late in someone’s life.
A meaningful share of claims succeed or settle in the claimant’s favour, especially where a spouse or child was left out entirely. Financial need carries real weight. So does the size of the estate. The wording of the will itself matters less than people expect.
There’s no fixed formula. Outcomes range from a modest adjustment to a significant share of the estate. Need and estate size both play a part, and so do any competing claims from other beneficiaries. Anyone offering a guaranteed figure before reviewing the details isn’t being straight with you.
Most estate planning problems are discovered too late, during probate, or when a family provision claim has already been filed. A consultation with a Specialist covers your Will, your asset structure, and whether what you have in place actually does what you intend.