Anyone asking about removing an executor in NSW is asking about an application to the Supreme Court, which will act when the estate isn’t being properly administered, whether through misconduct or unreasonable delay. Before probate is granted, the executor can renounce or the court can pass over a named executor. After the grant, the court revokes it and appoints a replacement.
Most people reach this question after a long wait with no explanation. I regularly see families put up with two, three or four years of “the house will be listed soon” before they take advice, and by then the estate has often lost money it can’t get back. Asking whether an executor can be replaced is a legitimate question, and the law gives it a defined answer.
Key takeaways
- Once probate has been granted, only the Supreme Court can remove an executor. Before the grant, renunciation or a caveat is usually faster and cheaper.
- The test is whether the estate can be duly and properly administered with this executor in place.
- An executor is conventionally given a year from the date of death. Silence beyond that point, with no explanation, counts as evidence in itself.
- Some families need only an order for accounts, which is narrower and quicker than removal.
- An unopposed application typically takes a few months. A contested hearing often runs 12 months or more.
What If The Executor Of A Will Takes Too Long?
An executor of a will in NSW is generally expected to complete the main work of administration within about a year of the death, and anything beyond that needs an explanation. When an executor can’t say what they’re waiting for, the question of removing an executor or seeking an order for accounts comes into view.
The executor’s year is a convention. Past it, an executor who has done nothing and won’t explain why is handing the court its first piece of evidence. Some delay is legitimate, and an executor who holds off distribution while the 12-month family provision window runs, or while a tax clearance comes through, is doing the job properly. The problem is the executor who can’t tell you what they’re waiting for.
An executor’s duties start when they accept the role, and the obligation to keep beneficiaries informed doesn’t pause while the executor waits for a better moment. Where an executor of a will is not doing anything visible, a written request for a status update, with a date for the reply, is the usual first step. Executors who ignore a solicitor’s letter rarely do themselves any favours. Each unanswered letter becomes an exhibit.
Delay costs real money. An executor who lets the two-year capital gains tax window on the deceased’s home close can wipe out a large share of what the beneficiaries would otherwise have received, and a house left sitting keeps generating bills.
On What Grounds Can An Executor Be Removed?
The recognised grounds for removing an executor are misconduct, incapacity, unreasonable delay, conflict of interest and unfitness, including a breakdown between co-executors. Each is measured against the same test: whether the estate can be duly and properly administered with this executor in place.
The test comes from Miller v Cameron, a High Court decision that treats the welfare of the beneficiaries as the guide, so it applies in NSW and across Australia. Judges don’t remove executors because the family dislikes them. They remove them because the estate isn’t being administered. Every piece of evidence should point back to that. If you can’t explain in one sentence why this executor has to go, you’re probably not ready to file. “She has not provided accounts despite six requests over eight months” works. “He’s impossible to deal with” doesn’t.
Misconduct covers misappropriation and self-dealing, and a refusal to account falls in the same group. An executor who simply sits on the estate can be removed for that alone. Wise v Barry [2018] is the clearest NSW example: a co-executor was removed after years of delay while he lived in the main asset with his family, with no finding of misconduct needed.
Co-executors raise a problem of their own. Where joint executors in NSW reach a standoff, a dispute between executors of a will can stall an estate as badly as a dishonest executor can, and the court won’t pick who’s “right”. It asks whether the estate can move. Eastlake v Eastlake [2015] found a breakdown between executors was enough on its own. When the difficulty sits with one executor, the court can remove that person and leave the others in place, as in Profilio v Profilio [1999] NSWSC 657 and McKerracher v McKerracher [2011] NSWSC 1288, vesting the property accordingly.
Incapacity calls for medical evidence. In Lawless v Donaldson [2012] NSWSC 570, the executor’s depression was offered as an explanation, and the court still gave the estate’s need for administration the greater weight.
Can A Beneficiary Remove An Executor?
A beneficiary can’t remove an executor directly, but a beneficiary is one of the people entitled to ask the Supreme Court to do it. That includes residuary beneficiaries, who take what remains after gifts and debts, and contingent beneficiaries whose entitlement depends on an event occurring. Co-executors can apply, and creditors can in some circumstances. A family member who isn’t a beneficiary generally can’t.
The rights of beneficiaries of a will begin with a right to expect the estate to be administered, and an executor’s obligations to beneficiaries include accounting for what has been done with the assets. Anyone weighing how to challenge the executor of a will, or considering removing an executor, needs standing first. Standing to apply for removal is narrower than standing to contest a will, which is a separate question with its own rules.
How To Remove An Executor Of A Will In NSW
The pathway for removing an executor of a will in NSW depends on whether the Supreme Court has granted probate, the formal confirmation of the will and of the executor’s authority to act under it.
Removing An Executor Before Probate
At this stage the executor can renounce, and a renunciation can resolve within weeks. A caveat can stop the grant being made while the dispute is worked out. The court can also pass over a named executor and give the grant to someone else. This route is faster and cheaper than anything available once the grant has issued, which is the main reason to move early.
Removing An Executor After Probate
Once the grant has been made, the application is a summons in the Probate List of the Supreme Court of NSW, seeking revocation of the grant and a new grant to a replacement. Where nobody opposes, the Registrar can sometimes deal with it. Where the executor opposes, the matter goes before a judge and the evidence carries the result.
Is Removal Of An Executor The Right Remedy?
Most people come in asking for removal of an executor. Many need an order for accounts, and an application matched to the problem saves time and costs.
An order to file and pass accounts is the first one to consider. The executor puts every receipt and payment in front of the court, and the court checks them. Some families only ever wanted that.
The court can also appoint an additional executor or an independent administrator to sit beside the existing one, and judicial advice settles a single point of disagreement. Security and supervision are reserved for estates where assets are exposed.
When removal is the right answer, NSW Trustee and Guardian is one replacement option. An independent solicitor or trustee company can also be appointed by consent, and families are often more comfortable with that.
A properly drafted letter setting out the grounds for removing an executor, and what defending an application would cost the executor, resolves more disputes than people expect, particularly before probate.
What Evidence Does The Court Expect?
A dated chronology of every request and every response is the foundation of an application for removing an executor, backed by whatever shows what has happened to the estate.
- Bank and estate records.
- Valuations for any asset whose value or sale is in question.
- Any sale or transfer that nobody has explained.
- Medical evidence, where incapacity is alleged.
- Affidavits from the other beneficiaries, which carry more weight when they describe the same events independently.
The chronology tends to carry the most weight, because it lets a judge see delay without anyone having to argue it.
Is An Executor Living In The Estate Home A Ground For Removal?
When the house forms part of the deceased estate, an executor living in it rent-free while the beneficiaries wait is in a conflict of interest, whether or not they’re also a beneficiary. An executor can be a beneficiary, and in many families one person is both, which is where this conflict most often arises. Occupation rent and an order to vacate can be sought alongside an application aimed at removing an executor, together with an order to account.
An executor who hands out items the will gives to named people, then tells the family they were promised elsewhere, is in plain breach. An executor’s personal view of what the deceased wanted carries no legal weight against the will.
Some wills excuse the executor from liability for losses caused by postponing a sale. Executors cite that clause to explain a house that is still unsold years later. Courts read it narrowly, and how far it stretches depends on the estate. Bad faith and wilful default fall outside it.
How Much Does It Cost To Remove An Executor?
The cost of removing an executor turns on one variable above the rest, which is whether the executor opposes. Renunciation before probate sits at the cheapest end, and an unopposed application after the grant comes next. A contested hearing is the most expensive path, and a matter that runs to trial costs far more again.
Clients put the question as “how much does it cost to remove an executor,” and the first thing to establish is whether the executor will fight. Each round of affidavits in reply adds to the bill, and hearing days add more. Medical evidence on incapacity and valuations of contested assets sit on top.
Who pays to have an executor removed is decided by the court at the end. Costs from the estate are discretionary, and an unsuccessful applicant can be ordered to pay the executor’s costs, which is a risk to weigh before filing. After removal, the new administrator can pursue the former executor for breach of trust if money is missing.
Ask for a written estimate before anything is filed, with the stages set out and the points at which it would change.
What Can An Executor Do If They Want Out?
After probate, or once an executor has dealt with estate property, resignation needs the court’s approval. The time to ask is early, because an estate that stalls while the executor decides is building the evidence for removing an executor.
The responsibilities and duties of an executor of a will are substantial, and the people carrying them are often grieving too. An executor of a will in NSW who is drawn into a contested estate can engage a solicitor and have reasonable costs met from the estate, and may be entitled to commission for work beyond an ordinary administration. Funeral costs paid out of pocket are reimbursed from the estate, and they’re paid early. An executor who raises a difficulty at the start is in a stronger position than one who goes quiet.
Speak To A Family Lawyer
If an executor has stopped answering you, bring the will and whatever correspondence exists. Book a confidential consultation with Hillcrest Family Legal to find out what the next step is. Sometimes the answer is just a letter. This article is general information and isn’t legal advice.
Removing An Executor FAQs
No. Only the Supreme Court can remove an executor once probate has been granted.
If the executor contests it, expect 12 months or more. Renunciation before probate can be done in weeks, and unopposed applications usually take a few months.
Write to the executor asking for an update by a set date, and keep a copy. Everything that follows, from an order to account to an application for removal, is built from that record of requests and replies.
Yes, and it happens often, with one child named as both executor and beneficiary. The duties to the other beneficiaries don't change. Trouble starts when that person takes the benefit first and the rest wait.
No fixed date applies from the grant. Executors commonly wait until the 12-month family provision window has closed, because a successful claim can change what is left to distribute, and funds held well beyond that point with no explanation are what send families looking for advice.




