Binding Death Benefit Nomination NSW: Is Super in an Estate?

The most common gap we see is a client who has made a will and assumes the super is handled. It isn’t. A will has no say over super unless the money is paid to the estate, and the fund isn’t bound by anything the will says. What does control it, in NSW, is a binding death benefit nomination.

Who gets paid, and how long they wait, turns on that nomination. Families often meet this for the first time after a death, when all that matters is what was signed and whether it had expired.

Key takeaways

  • Super is held on trust by the fund, so a will reaches it only if the money is paid to the estate.
  • A binding death benefit nomination removes the trustee’s discretion. A non-binding death benefit nomination gives the trustee a name to consider and nothing more.
  • Most binding death benefit nominations lapse after three years. A non-lapsing binding death benefit nomination exists only where the fund’s trust deed allows it.
  • Under the Succession Act 2006 (NSW), divorce revokes will gifts to a former spouse. A nomination is untouched.
  • Naming the estate gives your will control and, in NSW, puts the money within reach of a family provision claim. A direct nomination does not make super claim-proof either.

Is super part of your estate?

No. The fund trustee holds super on trust, so the member doesn’t own it outright when they die. It becomes estate property only if the trustee pays it to the legal personal representative (LPR), whoever administers the estate: the executor named in the will or, without one, an administrator.

Whatever a person owned in their own name forms the deceased estate. That’s the pool a will governs.

What the fund pays out is called the death benefit. It includes the account balance, any insured death cover, and earnings up to the payment date, less fees, premiums and tax. For many people, the life cover inside super is worth more than the balance, and it follows the same nomination.

What is a binding death benefit nomination?

A binding death benefit nomination is a written, signed direction to your super fund naming who receives your death benefit and in what shares. If it is valid and still in date, the trustee must pay as directed. A superannuation binding death benefit nomination removes the discretion the trustee would otherwise have.

Funds offer four types.

Type

Must the trustee follow it?

How long it lasts

What to check

Binding, lapsing

Yes, if valid

Usually three years

In some funds, it reverts to non-binding when it lapses

Non-lapsing binding death benefit nomination

Yes, if valid

Until you change or revoke it

Only available if the trust deed permits

Non-binding death benefit nomination

No

Depends on the fund

The trustee keeps discretion over who is paid

Reversionary

Applies to an income stream

Ongoing

The beneficiary must be a dependant

Each fund has its own binding death benefit nomination form. One with a witness missing, or a nominee the fund can’t accept, gets rejected.

The lapse is the trap in a lapsing binding death benefit nomination. Don’t rely on the fund to remind you. Some funds send a notice before a nomination lapses and some don’t, and a letter to an old address helps no one. Many binding death benefit nominations lapse unnoticed. The one point in favour of a lapse is that three years is long enough for a new partner or a new baby, so an expiring nomination forces another look at everything around it. The will should be read against the renewal, and so should the enduring power of attorney and enduring guardianship appointments.

Non-lapsing isn’t automatically better. A non-lapsing binding death benefit nomination is only as good as the last time you looked at it, and one that is valid but out of date is worse than having none, because the trustee has to follow it.

Who can you nominate?

Your legal personal representative, or a dependant as super law defines the term. Parents, siblings, friends, charities and pets can’t be nominated directly unless they meet the dependant test. The common misconception is that “direct family” is enough, and parents and siblings don’t qualify automatically.

Section 10(1) of the SIS Act defines a dependant as:

  • a spouse or de facto partner of any sex
  • a child of any age, including adopted children, stepchildren, ex-nuptial children and children under the Family Law Act (stepchild status can be contested, so take advice before relying on it)
  • a person in an interdependency relationship

Interdependency has four parts: a close personal relationship, living together, financial support, and domestic support and personal care. A disability variant applies where one person can’t meet a limb because of disability, and regulation 1.04AAAA of the SIS Regulations lists the factors a trustee weighs.

Name someone who isn’t eligible and the fund rejects the form. The usual answer is a binding death benefit nomination to the estate. You name your legal personal representative and the will takes over. A will can also set up a testamentary trust, which suits a child or anyone who needs the money managed for them. Tax law uses a different dependant definition, covered further down.

What makes a binding death benefit nomination valid?

Regulation 6.17A of the SIS Regulations sets the formalities. A valid binding death benefit nomination is in writing and signed, witnessed by two adults who are not beneficiaries, clear about each nominee’s share, and given to the trustee. The same regulation produces the three-year expiry.

Later events can undo a valid nomination. The deed may cancel it on a change in the member’s marital circumstances, and it fails if a nominee dies first or stops being a dependant.

A reversionary nomination and a binding one can also sit side by side, and for the pension balance the deed decides which wins. Trouble starts where the deed is silent.

Binding death benefit nomination SMSF rules

A binding death benefit nomination SMSF members sign is still needed, and the trust deed governs. In Hill v Zuda [2022] HCA 21, the High Court held that regulation 6.17A does not apply to SMSFs, which is why SMSF members can hold a non-lapsing binding death benefit nomination.

The complexity comes from the law, not just from the funds. Reform has been floated, including in a submission from the Law Council of Australia, but the rules above are the ones that apply now.

Does separation, marriage or divorce change a nomination?

Not automatically. The will is another matter. Under section 12 of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW) marriage revokes it, and under section 13, divorce revokes gifts to a former spouse in a will. Neither section reaches super.

A couple separate and never divorce. Seven or eight years later the wife dies, and her husband receives all of her super and insurance while her new partner receives nothing. Updating her will would not have changed that. Only a new nomination would have.

Binding vs non-binding death benefit nomination: which should you use?

If you know who should receive the money, use a binding nomination and review it regularly.

A non-binding death benefit nomination only tells the trustee who to consider. Who gets paid stays the trustee’s call. The law constrains what a trustee can decide. A discretion still means months of waiting, sometimes longer, and room for anyone left off the list to dispute it.

Binding death benefit nominations give certainty, faster payment and few grounds for challenge. Their drawbacks are inflexibility, since the trustee can’t adapt to circumstances at the date of death, and the risk of conflict with the rest of your estate plan. It can also expire without you noticing.

Should super go to your estate or to a dependant directly?

It is a trade-off, and with a binding death benefit nomination, NSW law adds a family provision layer on top. Directing super to your estate gives your will control, which is how you get testamentary trusts and protection for young or vulnerable beneficiaries. In NSW, it also puts the money squarely within reach of a family provision claim.

Some commentators say to nominate the estate only when you have to. For a straightforward family with an obvious recipient, that holds. It holds less well for a blended family or a young beneficiary.

A direct nomination does not make super claim-proof either. Under sections 75 to 90 of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW), the Supreme Court can designate property outside the estate as a notional estate in a family provision claim, and that can include super paid under a binding death benefit nomination. The court acts only where the section 80 conditions are met. This is where NSW differs from what interstate sources describe, Victoria’s among them, so check the jurisdiction of any guide you rely on.

Can a binding death benefit nomination be challenged?

Yes, on narrow grounds. Validity, capacity and formalities are the grounds, and unfairness alone is not one. In NSW, the realistic route for a disappointed family member is a family provision claim through the notional estate provisions above.

How is a super death benefit taxed, and who can receive it?

The binding death benefit nomination tax implications turn on who receives the money. A spouse receives a death benefit tax-free. An adult child who wasn’t financially dependent pays tax on the taxable component.

Tax law defines a dependant as a spouse or former spouse, a child under 18, an interdependent person, or anyone financially dependent on the deceased. An adult child has to have been financially dependent to qualify. For adult children, routing the benefit through the estate can in some circumstances avoid the Medicare levy on the taxable component, and an accountant should confirm that before anything is signed.

Dependants can take a lump sum or an income stream. Non-dependants can take a lump sum only. A child can receive an income stream if under 18, or under 25 and financially dependent, or permanently disabled, and the benefit must be cashed out at 25 unless the child has a disability.

You may see advice online to withdraw all your super before death. That is a financial adviser’s call. If an attorney cashes out super under a power of attorney to steer it into an estate they benefit from, that can breach their duties unless the power expressly authorises it.

What happens if there is no nomination?

The trustee can pay one or more dependants, or pay the LPR. If no dependant or LPR turns up after reasonable enquiries, the trustee follows the deed or sends the money to the ATO as unclaimed under regulation 6.22. Super paid to an estate with no will passes under NSW intestacy rules, and where there are no eligible relatives it goes to the State.

On intestacy, section 133 of the Succession Act lets an estate be distributed under Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander customs. Super law has no equivalent: a brother, or a niece raised as a daughter, qualifies as a dependant only if the relationship meets the interdependency test. A 2019 Treasury paper looked at this and was only a consultation, and the definition has not changed since.

What will the fund ask for after a death?

Dealing with a fund while grieving is hard enough, and the paperwork rarely helps. Expect to prove the death and the relationship: a death certificate, a marriage certificate, ID and payment instructions. A valid nomination removes the trustee’s discretion, not the paperwork. Experiences differ on how much a fund asks for, but a valid binding nomination to a spouse shouldn’t require proof of financial dependency. If a fund asks, ask why, escalate inside the fund first and then take it to the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA).

When should you review a nomination?

Review it when your circumstances change, and keep a copy of the signed binding death benefit nomination form with your will:

  • marriage or a new relationship
  • children or grandchildren
  • divorce or separation
  • illness

Tell your beneficiaries which fund you’re with as well. Nobody can claim from a fund they don’t know exists.

Checking a nomination against your will

A nomination and a will are read by different people under different rules, so they need to be checked against each other. Hillcrest Family Legal reviews the fund’s deed, the nomination and the will together, and acts for families dealing with a fund after a death. You can book a confidential consultation to go through your position.

This article is general information and not legal advice.

Frequently asked questions

Not unless it is paid to your legal personal representative. Super is held in trust by the fund, so your will doesn't deal with it directly.

No. A valid binding nomination is paid as directed, whatever the will says.

Three years, usually. After that the nomination lapses, and some funds then treat it as a non-binding death benefit nomination, so the trustee is free to decide. A non-lapsing binding death benefit nomination has no end date, but only where the trust deed allows one.

Yes, but only on narrow grounds: validity, capacity or formalities. In NSW a family provision claim can still reach the money through the notional estate provisions.

No. Divorce revokes will gifts to a former spouse under section 13 of the Succession Act, but a nomination stays in force unless the fund's deed cancels it on divorce. Update the nomination as soon as the divorce order is made, and read the deed in the meantime.

You can complete the fund's binding death benefit nomination form yourself. A binding death benefit nomination lawyer adds value where the nomination has to work with a will, a blended family or a testamentary trust, since a form that is valid on its own can still cut across the rest of your plan.

Start Your Legal Journey With Us Today

Contact Hillcrest Family Lawyers for expert guidance and compassionate support. Let’s discuss how we can help you navigate your family law matters.

hillcrest
Sydney's premier choice for all family law matters, divorce, child custody and other family law matters specialist